The two largest active adult new-construction communities in Collier County compared. Same Collier County tax advantage. Very different locations, price points, CDD exposure, and amenity approaches. The decision framework for buyers choosing between them.
Del Webb Naples and Valencia Trails are the two communities that come up most often when buyers ask about new construction 55+ options in Collier County. Both benefit from Collier County's lower tax rate. Both are active construction phases. Both are large resort communities with strong programming. But the location difference is 25 miles and the price difference is substantial. Here is what actually separates them.
Have questions about what you're reading? A specialist can walk you through real costs, honest comparisons, and what's actually available right now — free, no obligation.
Talk to a Specialist →Del Webb Naples is significantly less expensive in a significantly more remote location. Valencia Trails is significantly more expensive in a significantly better-located position within the Naples metro.
| Factor | Del Webb Naples (Ave Maria) | Valencia Trails (N. Naples) |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Ave Maria — 30 mi east of Naples | Immokalee Rd — north Naples metro |
| Distance to Naples beach | ~45–50 min | ~25–30 min |
| Distance to RSW airport | ~45 min | ~25 min |
| Planned homes | 2,123 | ~850 |
| Builder | PulteGroup / Del Webb | GL Homes |
| Price range | ~$300K–$700K | ~$550K–$1M+ |
| HOA | ~$200–$350/mo | ~$400–$600/mo |
| CDD | Yes — $125–$292/mo equiv. | None most parcels |
| Golf | No on-site golf | No on-site golf |
| True all-in est. (base case) | ~$725–$1,100/mo | ~$1,100–$1,650/mo |
Del Webb Naples looks dramatically cheaper on HOA alone ($200–$350 vs $400–$600). But the CDD adds $125–$292/month back, and the true HOA-plus-CDD range is $325–$642/month. That still compares favorably to Valencia Trails' HOA-only range of $400–$600/month. Del Webb Naples is genuinely less expensive to carry monthly — on the order of $200–$550/month less depending on specific home price and CDD phase.
On a 20-year hold, that monthly savings represents $48,000–$132,000 in cumulative carrying cost advantage for Del Webb Naples. That is not a rounding error — it is a meaningful financial argument for buyers who are comfortable with the location trade-off.
Both communities deliver excellent Del Webb / GL Homes resort amenities, new construction quality, and Collier County's lower tax rate. The only meaningful question is: can you live happily 30 miles from Naples, or do you need to be in the Naples metro with 25-minute beach access and North Naples commercial corridor proximity? Everything else — price, CDD, HOA — follows from how you answer that question. Tour both communities, but be honest about how you want to spend your days before the financial math takes over.
We connect buyers with agents who know this market from the inside — real cost math, honest comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder. No scripts, no pressure.
Del Webb Naples' Maple Ridge Activity Center (resort pools, fitness, ballroom, pickleball, bocce, art studio) is a genuinely excellent Del Webb amenity center. Valencia Trails' 37,000+ sq ft resort center (resort and lap pools, spa, fitness, culinary kitchen, pickleball, tennis, bocce, nature trails) is larger and includes a spa and culinary program that Del Webb Naples doesn't offer at the same scale. For buyers who prioritize the amenity experience, Valencia Trails' facility is more comprehensive. For buyers who will use the community moderately, both deliver more than enough.
Your budget is $300K–$600K and you want the best quality active adult community at that price point in Collier County. You prioritize low monthly carrying cost over location convenience. You are genuinely community-oriented and the Del Webb programming will be your primary social and activity structure. You don't need daily Naples access and are comfortable with the 30-mile remove.
You want a Naples metro address with 25-minute beach access and full commercial corridor proximity. Your budget is $550K+ and the Collier County tax advantage is meaningful at your price point even at the higher HOA. GL Homes' resort amenity scale and nature trail environment are important to you. You want a community with no CDD complexity on most parcels.
We can build a complete monthly cost model for both communities at your specific budget before you tour either one.
Get Free Help →Connect with a specialist who knows this market from the inside — real cost math, honest community comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder.
Connect with a Specialist →