What Nobody Tells You · Del Webb Maygrass
Del Webb Maygrass: 8 Things to Know Before You Buy
The brochure sells the clubhouse. These are the details that actually shape whether Maygrass is right for you — from the all-ages sibling community to the construction timeline.
Del Webb Maygrass is a genuinely exciting addition to Central Ohio — the first true resort-style 55+ community the market has had. But “exciting” and “right for you” are different questions. Here is what we would want a friend to know before touring.
1. The Del Webb name down the road is NOT age-restricted
Del Webb Explore at Northstar in Sunbury carries the same brand but is open to all ages — it can have families with school-age children. Maygrass in Plain City is the genuine 55+ community. People tour the wrong one and leave confused. Confirm you are at the Plain City address if age restriction is the point.
2. Plain City is genuinely west — plan your drives
Maygrass is convenient to Dublin and Bridge Park (about ten minutes to I-270) but it is on the western edge of the metro. Trips to the east side, John Glenn Columbus International Airport, or New Albany medical campuses are real drives. If your grandkids or your cardiologist are on the east side, factor the commute before you fall for the clubhouse.
3. The indoor pool is the feature that earns its keep
In Ohio, an outdoor pool is useful maybe five months a year. Maygrass’s indoor pool is what makes the amenity package genuinely year-round. When you compare it to communities with outdoor-only water, you are not comparing like for like — the indoor pool is half the reason the HOA is what it is.
4. You will live in a construction zone for years
With 711 homes planned across 353 acres, early buyers move into an active build-out. Expect construction traffic, partial amenities at first, and a community that does not feel “full” until later phases close. Buying early gets you first pick of lots; it also means patience while the neighborhood fills in.
5. The HOA is higher than the Epcon alternative — on purpose
A staffed clubhouse, a lifestyle director, two pools, and structured programming cost money. Maygrass’s HOA runs meaningfully above a small Epcon Courtyards association. That is fair value if you use the clubs and classes; it is dead weight if you mostly want a quiet ranch and a mowed lawn.
6. Ohio taxes your pension — budget for it
Buyers relocating from no-income-tax states are often blindsided. Ohio does not tax Social Security and fully exempts military retirement, but pensions, IRA, and 401(k) withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income (flat 2.75% in 2026). That is a line item in your Ohio retirement budget that did not exist in Florida or Texas.
7. The taxing district — not the city name — sets your bill
Plain City sits near the Union and Madison County lines, and the precise school and taxing district drives your effective property tax rate. Two homes a mile apart can carry different bills. Never trust a generic “Columbus is affordable” figure — get the parcel-specific number before you sign.
8. Resale is unproven here — you are an early adopter
Because Maygrass is brand new, there is no resale track record in this specific community yet. Del Webb resale tends to hold up well nationally, but in a market historically dominated by Epcon, how Maygrass resells against established Courtyards neighborhoods is still an open question. Buy it for the lifestyle, not as a sure-thing flip.
Want an unbiased second opinion?
We are not paid by the builder. Tell us what matters to you and we will tell you honestly whether Maygrass or an Epcon community fits better.
Talk it through